Expected behaviour when creating list using toolbar

We can use Joplin's editor toolbar to convert a selection into list.image

can you please provide your opinion on what should be the behaviour of this button in situation described below .

  1. content of the editor is
text1
text2

text3 

(third line is empty)

  1. select all lines from text1 to text3
  2. convert the selection to list using toolbar button.

Now which lines should be converted to list items ?

  1. All four (current behaviour of joplin)
    image
  2. 1st 2nd and 4th
    image
  3. 1st and 2nd only
    image

Here's the link to related Pull_Request And Issue on github

1 Like

What do other Markdown editors do? Like StackExchange, Discourse, etc.?

option 1: libreoffice,google docs,github

image

option 2: discourse,ms-word

image

StackExchange:treats all the lines like first item of a list
image

This topic was automatically closed 60 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.