The attachment file content is not synchronized after modification, please assist

s4j4 · 2020-05-07T05:00:02.601Z

After opening the attachment and editing it, the edited attachment cannot be synchronized. I hope it can be added to the optimization project so that the attachment can be synchronized after editing. Thank you

kowalskidev · 2020-05-07T05:11:52.999Z

CalebJohn:

. I actually tried once, but it’s rather complicated.

We can do something like adding a background service which keep tracks of synced attachments and if there's any change in attachment (change in "last modified date" metadata) then it will re-sync that note with edited attachment.. just a thought....I'm not sure if it works

s4j4 · 2020-05-07T05:20:02.043Z

The modified attachments cannot be synchronized, which is the biggest problem I encountered when using Joplin. Thank you for your suggestions, and I look forward to the development team having a good solution.

CalebJohn · 2020-05-07T05:31:14.482Z

Yes absolutely, the structure could be similar to the external editor.
Another option is to mark any opened attached as dirty by adding a hash of the attachment. On sync the dirty attachments would be checked against the hashes and the changed ones could be synced. This would avoid the necessity of running a background service.

kowalskidev · 2020-05-07T06:13:04.351Z

CalebJohn:

Another option is to mark any opened attached as dirty by adding a hash of the attachment. On sync the dirty attachments would be checked against the hashes and the changed ones could be synced.

Yes that would be more efficient and robust...but could be a tough implementation

s4j4 · 2020-05-20T06:29:28.202Z

Does the development team see this problem? Can it be solved? Thank you

mrkjhnstn · 2020-05-23T18:20:44.141Z

Just to chime in on this - as a new Joplin user, loving it but very surprised that changes to attachments are not synching, and there doesn’t seem to be a way to force that to occur. Add my vote to finding a solution for this, please!

s4j4 · 2020-06-05T08:51:47.742Z

The inability to synchronize after the attachment is edited is a major defect of Joplin, and I hope that the development team will fix it first after seeing it. Thank you

CalebJohn · 2020-06-05T16:42:49.773Z

Looks like this feature was just merged in a couple of days ago. Please be patient it should be available soon.

s4j4 · 2020-06-06T00:36:30.458Z

Great, thank you very much.

ChristopheDavid · 2020-12-22T20:58:21.026Z

CalebJohn:

Looks like this feature was just merged in a couple of days ago. Please be patient it should be available soon

I recently discovered and migrated to Joplin (1.4.19, Linux), which does everything I need to do, except synchronising attachments properly. Googling for this led me to this thread.

Would someone please update on this issue ? Is there a workaround if it is not fixed yet ?

Thank you in anticipation.

CalebJohn · 2020-12-22T21:27:38.490Z

Hi @ChristopheDavid

As far as I know there aren't any known issues with this feature. If you have encountered an issue please open a new thread on the forum that describes your problem in more detail.

Thanks.

ChristopheDavid · 2020-12-23T11:42:26.223Z

CalebJohn:

As far as I know there aren't any known issues with this feature.

Thank you for the fast reply.

After checking, it looks like everything works fine for new attachments.

What I had noticed is that after I turned on encryption and shared the synchronisation folder using SyncThing, when importing on a new device the notes were encrypted properly but the attachments were lost.

Since then (no new configuration change), new attachments are shared correctly.

Not sure it is worth a new specific topic, but maybe something to double check in the future.

Thanks again for your help and for this very useful piece of software.

MrMacvos · 2021-01-14T11:09:17.722Z

This doesn't seem to work for PDFs? I have just changed a PDF and synced, then on my other devices started a sync, but on the other devices, the PDF is still the 'old' PDF. Is there a way to force-sync attachments?

CalebJohn · 2021-01-14T17:11:31.253Z

Can you confirm which version you're on? And which Os.

When you open a pdf from a note, there should be a big message that appears across the top of Joplin, do you see this?

MrMacvos · 2021-01-14T17:52:05.439Z

Yes, that's what I see when I open the PDF by clicking the link.
However, I needed it to open with a different PDF editor, and Joplin has no 'Open with...' menu-item so I right-clicked the PDF-link, choose 'Show in Finder' and edited the attachment there directly.

roman_r_m · 2021-01-14T20:31:19.189Z

When you do this Joplin can not detect the attachment has been changed and won't sync your change.

CalebJohn · 2021-01-14T20:41:57.226Z

Joplin uses the default pdf viewer on you OS. You can change it in the OS settings, i don't know what OS you use so I can't help beyond that, but you can just search online for how to do it.

MrMacvos · 2021-01-15T09:22:47.518Z

I know that, and that's ok. It's just a bit strange having to change the default app first when I want a PDF-editor to open a PDF instead of the default PDF-viewer.

roman_r_m · 2021-01-15T10:35:32.541Z

I agree it would be useful to have something like "Open with" on Windows. Not sure if it's possible with electron though.