Desktop app: Opening/editing multiple notes

rxliuli · 2021-06-02T13:34:22.737Z

If editing functions are important to you, I still recommend external editors, which are more professional text editors.

robotcorner · 2021-06-03T05:23:27.765Z

I happen to STRONGLY disagree that viewing multiple notes and being able to edit them side by side is not useful. This seems the best method to condense sets of notes into coherent larger notes. This has been my workflow anyway with word, vs-code, or other apps throughout my life the past 10+ years. To think that this is not a very useful feature to me seems shortsighted to your immediate use case only. Developers can spend time on what they want, but I wouldn't discourage a new developer away from thinking this is a useful feature if they want to contribute their time. They wouldn't put this feature in a large majority of the other popular apps if it wasn't useful.

Iutech · 2021-06-03T07:18:01.317Z

rxliuli:

If editing functions are important to you, I still recommend external editors, which are more professional text editors.

Why not, what is the workflow you would propose in such situations ?

rxliuli · 2021-06-03T08:00:58.578Z

ref # Personal Experience Sharing: Using Joplin + VSCode as a Note-Taking Tool

Iutech · 2021-06-04T08:33:42.566Z

Thanks, but I don't see anything there that answers my question ?

rxliuli · 2021-06-04T11:16:43.268Z

Open two notes side by side

image2498×1440 225 KB

Compare two notes

image1253×858 70.4 KB

Iutech · 2021-06-04T11:38:38.249Z

Thanks, that is exactly what I want to do.
How do you achieve this ? If I'm not mistaken, it's not explained in the above link...

rxliuli · 2021-06-04T11:53:09.789Z

This is a function of VSCode, let me explain. . . You can take a look here:

Window segmentation: Visual Studio Code June 2018
Compare two files: Visual Studio Code - is there a Compare feature like that plugin for Notepad ++? - Stack Overflow

If you have never been in contact with a professional editor before, it is recommended to take a look at VSCode's series of video tutorials (you can skip the programming related parts)

code.visualstudio.com

Visual Studio Code Introductory Videos

Overview of Visual Studio Code's introductory videos.

Iutech · 2021-06-04T14:04:51.403Z

OK, the image shows the process clearly, thanks. The part that is done in VSCode, at least.
But what is your workflow between Joplin and VSCode since, if I understand correctly, you advise me to open my Joplin notes with VSCode if I want to compare files or segment the window ?

Again, I couldn't find an explanation about how to do that in the links that you provided.

rxliuli · 2021-06-04T15:18:23.872Z

In general, I use both vscode and joplin at the same time, so use joplin-vscode-plugin to connect them, nothing more.

test 2

vscode has many excellent features, I can't list them all (the official document will do it), I just explain the features related to joplin notes (mainly some plug-ins)

bbusschots · 2021-09-24T09:51:48.108Z

I just want to add my voice here and say that this is extremely basic functionality, and that as a new user I am literally stunned that something so basic is missing in an app that has been around for so long.

I assumed I was just being dumb and that I was missing the obvious "open in new window" button, but alas no, the app assumes people only want one note at a time. That may be true for some, but it's absolutely not true for me.

I REALLY want to get away from EverNote, and there is so much that is right about Joplin, but this is just an absolute clanger — I've paid for a year of cloud, but at this stage I feel like I've wasted my money and am going to be forced back to EverNote

johano · 2021-09-24T14:04:30.715Z

Have you tried adding the Note Tabs plugin?

Daeraxa · 2021-09-24T16:50:03.209Z

What functionality are you lacking by being able to open the note in an external editor rather than the Joplin editor? I tend to use Joplin directly for editing a note and open up any additional notes in MarkText if I want to compare. Otherwise I'll open them up in a proper IDE.

bbusschots · 2021-09-24T23:02:43.317Z

I have — it's better than nothing, but still only shows one note at any one time. I can't spread my notes out across my screen, nor can I have different notes in different spaces. I'm a HUGE spaces user, and a huge note taker, I have always been able to have the right note in the right space depending on what task I am working on. I feel utterly trapped in Joplin

bbusschots · 2021-09-24T23:04:56.825Z

I tried that — it's a dirty hack. Each note has a different copy of the editor in the task switcher, and the windows all have cryptic names so you can't tell which note is which.

The ability to open multiple notes is table stakes. I'm SHOCKED that people are surprised people might want such trivially basic functionality. I never expected to be asked to justify the most basic basic basic feature of an app on a WINDOWED OS.

I'm asking for some butter for my bread, and people are reacting as if I'd asked for a golden spoon!

Daeraxa · 2021-09-24T23:25:04.928Z

My, we do have a flair for the dramatic don't we? Generally it doesn't tend to go down well when one joins a community and then acts up against the people attempting to help and explain.

If this functionality was truly as basic a requirement as you claim then it would be in the application. The fact is that it hasn't therefore means it can't be a "basic basic basic" feature or it would have made it in long ago. I rarely have more than one or two notes open at once, if I wanted more then I would use something like @rxliuli's vscode-plugin which works extremely well and leverages all of the power of a full on IDE/editor.

Joplin has a lot of happy users and sure, I imagine some or a lot of them would like this feature (I mean, I wouldn't exactly say no) but it is hardly a dealbreaker for the masses or it wouldn't have a userbase this large and I personally would prefer for other things to be developed in preference.

There are plenty of other note applications out there, if your particular workflow is so intrinsically tied to the features of an application then I would advise using them for a bit first to work out which one actually suits your needs best - there is never going to be a one size fits all solution.

rxliuli · 2021-09-25T03:19:42.674Z

In fact, the real advantage of multi-tab pages is that they can display two at the same time for comparison, which is not practical for most people, including programmers who spend most of their time focusing on a few files and then quickly switching files.
But if this ability is very important to you, then you can use a professional external editor, such as vscode + joplin-vscode-plugin, each choice is a trade-off and trade-off.

https://joplin-utils.rxliuli.com/joplin-vscode-plugin/

Most of the time I open two files at the same time for comparison(git), IDE even has a special editing mode to support displaying only the file currently being edited, just like joplin's default behavior

Full use of vscode will give up part of the joplin plugins, but you can also use some of the vscode plugins. This is also a choice for us. If joplin does show some "essential" plugins, maybe we will choose to use them at the same time

bbusschots · 2021-09-25T06:58:53.072Z

Ah, I see, I’m holding it wrong.

I have my notes app open permanently. I can’t work without my various how-tos. I use spaces to compartmentalise my work. Different tasks, with different how-tos in different spaces. I simply open note in new window and spread them around the different spaces. With
Joplin I can only quickly access my how-tos in one space, so for one task.

The tabs plug-in doesn’t help at all — it’s just bookmarks for jumping between single notes in a single window a little easier.

An external editor does give different windows, but I can’t cmd-tab to the notes because each window is a separate instance of the editor so my task switcher is full of identical copies of the same app — picking one is simply pot-luck, pick the wrong one, and you jump spaces! You can’t even distinguish them by window title because the file names the external editor sees are some kind of hex uuid that are obviously meant for computers rather than humans.

All the focus in this conversation seems to be on writing notes, not using them. I write maybe one or two notes a week, but I read my notes all the time, copying and pasting terminal commands to get my work done.

I’ve paid Evernote for years as they made their app worse and worse and worse. I am happy to pay for an open source product instead — in fact, I have, I bought a year of Joplin Cloud (and not the cheap version). The problem is, I can’t get my work done efficiently anymore. It seems I need to pay more to get a worse experience, and I should apparently be happy about that.

My experience switching to Joplin has been terrible. If the community want to make a great app you should want to understand how your app has driven a frustrated Evernote user right back to Evernote against his will. This should be a learning opportunity.

Instead, the response is a defensive insistence than my use case is nuts, and I must be somehow stupid for not doing things just like you do.

Daeraxa · 2021-09-25T13:17:41.856Z

bbusschots:

Ah, I see, I’m holding it wrong.

No, you bought a spanner when what you wanted was a screwdriver

bbusschots:

but I can’t cmd-tab to the notes because each window is a separate instance of the editor so my task switcher is full of identical copies of the same app

This depends on the application you are opening it in though. If I choose atom as my external editor then it opens up each file within a single instance of atom.

bbusschots:

My experience switching to Joplin has been terrible. If the community want to make a great app you should want to understand how your app has driven a frustrated Evernote user right back to Evernote against his will. This should be a learning opportunity.

So far all you have done is complain about a single aspect of the application that you see as essential and that others do not. Other than "I want this feature and the application I chose doesn't have it", what else has been particularly terrible? If the lack of that feature is the only part that is making the experience so miserable then why choose an application that doesn't support it?
Many of us already consider Joplin a "great app" and it is getting better all the time with the various plugins and community support and contributions.
Your insinuation that Joplin isn't good seems to be based on a singular issue that is essential to you, clearly not everyone shares your opinion.

bbusschots:

Instead, the response is a defensive insistence than my use case is nuts, and I must be somehow stupid for not doing things just like you do.

Not at all, in fact the conclusion that I have come to (not speaking for others) is that Joplin doesn't suit your workflow and requirements.
I picked Joplin after using EverNote and OneNote for years. In fact I still use OneNote at work because I have a very different workflow and use case for it - I require the simple and flexible layout and embedding system rather than the ease of writing afforded to me by markdown in Joplin. I also require it more for accessing and reading notes for info, previous solutions etc. than for actually typing into it, the majority of stuff I enter is just copy and pasted in.

After the changes in Evernote to the new and (certainly at the time) inferior Electron desktop app I went on a hunt for various alternatives that suited my use case for an evernote replacement.
My main requirements were (although not all hard requirements):

Free and open source
Markdown support or something similar rather than richtext
Simple notebook/notes hierarchy
Tagging support
Device syncing
Mobile app
Multi-platform (which immediately excludes quite a few like Bear for macOS)

I had a look at a bunch of different applications and tried them out to see if they suited me. If I look at your main requirement of being able to throw up multiple windows all over the place to look at and see how other applications perform this (consider that I don't have much experience with most of these, I just downloaded them for some very brief testing to see if I liked them).

Obsidian
- Allows you to compare notes within the same pane but doesn't seem to allow you to open them as new windows
- Allows you to open files directly with an external editor in the same way as Joplin - albeit with the file names as the backend is simply a "vault" of md files rather than an sql database.
- You can open a different "vault" of folders in another window.
QOwnNotes
- Opens different notes in tabs but also allows individual note windows with a reduced UI
Standard Notes
- Does not support opening multiple notes
Notable
- Supports opening in external applications but not windows within app

As you can see, this "basic" behaviour of yours is treated very differently in each one. Only one of them supports the exact functionality you are after.

There are obviously loads more apps out there, these are just some of the ones I found that tended towards being open source and free with markdown support. You might not care about the open source aspect which would open up an entire wealth of paid and free applications out there that might suit your needs but you cannot expect the features of a given application to bend to your particular workflow.

Don't blame the application because it doesn't have a feature you require, if this was so important to your workflow then you should take it for a test drive before taking the plunge.
If there is enough community support for it and if somebody wants spend the time and effort add this functionality to the app then sure, it could well feature it in the future, otherwise it seems you have simply picked the wrong tool for the job.

MrMacvos · 2021-10-07T08:07:14.443Z

I used Evernote before, too, and switched a year ago for the same reason you mention... worse, worse, and more worse. Trying out various other note-taking apps, I ended at Joplin. I also missed the multiple window feature, at first. After arguing about almost the same 'wishes' you have, I reviewed the way I worked and asked if this was really something I needed. Turns out, I didn't. It was just a handy feature of the old Evernote. Also Evernote only allowed one window in their newer, 'better' version. I also tried open -n /Applications/Joplin.app in Terminal to start a new instance to get my multiple-window feature, but that doesn't work with Joplin.

So, I looked at how I can still switch fast between notes I use a lot when working on projects. Tags and the tabs-plugin are the way to go. By using tags the right way, I can filter a certain list of notes I use often together. And the tabs-plugin for quick switching between projects.

Also, these guys are not sitting still. Since I joined Joplin, a lot has changed for the better, it's not getting worse.